The default comparison is usually unfair to someone
Ask three window companies for a quote without specifying material, style and replacement method, and you'll often get three answers to three different questions. That's not necessarily anyone trying to mislead you; it's what happens when each company defaults to what it sells most often.
A dealer that mainly moves vinyl inserts will quote a vinyl insert unless told otherwise. A factory-direct crew built around full-frame installs will quote full-frame unless told otherwise. Neither company is wrong to do that; they're both answering the question as asked, which is exactly why the question needs to be more specific before you send it to three companies at once.
Start every bid request from the same written scope
California's licensing board recommends collecting at least three written bids, each one responding to an identical set of plans and a matched scope, specifically so the resulting numbers are comparable rather than guessed at after the fact.[1]
Washington's Department of Labor & Industries gives similar advice for any contractor bid: get at least three written estimates and compare them carefully before you commit to one.[2]
Specify these four things before you ask for a number
Frame material and product line, not just a brand name. Full-frame or insert replacement, not left to the installer's default. Glass package, including whether it's certified for your ENERGY STAR zone. And whether disposal of the old windows is included or billed separately.
A quote that's silent on any of these four is a quote for an undefined job, and comparing it to a fully specified quote from a competitor tells you almost nothing.
Put the comparison in the contract, not just the quote
Washington's contractor-disclosure rules require a written notice to customers on qualifying residential jobs, spelling out the registration number, bond information and lien risk before work starts, which is exactly the kind of paperwork that should carry over from quote to signed contract without changes.[3]
California requires a written contract for home improvement work over $500 in combined labor and materials, with any changes afterward also required to be in writing, which is worth confirming applies the same way to whichever company you choose.[4]
Watch for a bid that's priced to win, not to finish the job
California's licensing board specifically flags being wary of a bid that comes in far below the others on an identical scope, since an unusually low number sometimes means a narrower scope hiding behind the same words, not a better deal.[1]
Bringing it back to brand comparisons
Once you've picked a product line using the brand comparisons on this site, send the exact same spec, material, style and replacement method to every company you ask for a bid. That's the only way the price difference you see actually reflects installer cost and markup, rather than three companies quoting three different jobs.